State of Yard Management Industry Report
Learn how Fortune 500 companies are using yard management technology to optimize one of the most complex and costly aspects of the modern supply chain: the yard.
What Is a Yard Management System?
At its most basic, a Yard Management System (YMS) is a software solution designed to monitor the movement of trailers in the yard of a facility, distribution center or warehouse. As the bridge between transportation and warehouse, your yard management software can create valuable opportunities for agility and efficiency.
Transportation → Yard → Warehouse
Recent supply chain turbulence has led many organizations to consider how to optimize their yard operations. A key tool in yard optimization is a yard management solution, but these can take many forms, including a warehouse management system add-on, a standalone solution, a homegrown system and others. Critical to determining the best solution for your organization is understanding your options.
Today’s Yard Management Challenges
While yard management presents unique challenges for every organization – depending on the size of the company and the yard, products present on the yard and many other factors – here are the key issues we have discovered during our conversations with yard operations associates all over the world.
Lack of trailer visibility
Yard teams do not have enough insight into available trailer assets in the yard (and possibly inventory), leading to inefficient movement of trailers, increased cost and decreased jockey efficiency.
Lack of shipment visibility
Yard teams do not have advanced insight into when trucks will enter the yard for loading or unloading, resulting in inefficient use of the yard and its resources. Additionally, gate congestion and demurrage/detention charges skyrocket.
Transportation, warehouse and yard processes are either managed via different platforms that do not dynamically update or are not digitally maintained at all, leading to reactive operations. This means stakeholders do not have insights into what’s happening in real time, leading to inefficient use of warehouse dock doors, labor and equipment, as well as increased costs. Moreover, inefficient use of transportation resources leads to higher wait times, costs and delays, which can negatively impact customer relationships.
Yard jockey inefficiency
Lack of insight into yard operations results in inefficient use of yard jockeys and an inability to monitor operations for safety and compliance. This leads to increased violations and charges, as well as wasted jockey labor and poor planning.
The State of Yard Management: Industry Report 2021
Download this report to find out how hundreds of Fortune 500 companies are using yard management technology to optimize one of the most complex and costly aspects of the modern supply chain: the yard.
Key Benefits of a Yard Management System (YMS)
When investing in yard management software, it’s important to understand the impact it can have for your organization, and what you should prioritize when searching for the right solution. On the importance of an effective YMS, Gartner’s Market Guide for Yard Management had this to say:
Shorter transportation lead times and increasing transportation costs push companies to increase their efficiencies in the yard, as time spent on a yard can be unproductive and costly… Consequently, it becomes even more critical for shippers to find time savings elsewhere in their supply chains. Boosting throughput by using a YMS means trucks spend more minutes with their wheels turning.
– Gartner’s Market Guide for Yard Management
Visibility into yard operations and assets enables effective performance measurement and inventory management. Eliminate time wasted searching for “lost” trailers on the yard. When yard management software integrates with other systems (TMS, WMS, in-transit visibility platform, etc.) organizations have increased line of sight into performance and assets.
Modern yard management systems assist in the automation of traditionally manual processes in the yard, like gate-in, gate-out and appointment scheduling. This leads to increased accuracy of inputs and outputs for better benchmarking. A modern YMS provides shippers and 3PLs with reports and analytics for effective KPI setting and measurement. When performance expectations aren’t satisfactorily met, managers can quickly pinpoint which functions of the supply chain need intervention. With optimized process management, organizations can expect an improvement in the flow of materials through a facility, maximizing utilization of yard and warehouse labor.
One of the most important roles of a yard management solution is the reduction of costs across an organization’s yard operations. An effective YMS will lead to a reduction in demurrage and detention expenses by automating and digitizing processes, and managing appointments to ensure smooth carrier operations. Organizations can also expect a reduction in labor costs, as yard workers will waste less time making calls, searching for inventory, completing manual tasks and waiting idly.
For continual improvement, it’s critical to have visibility into the performance of every aspect of the supply chain. By tracking carrier commitments, on-time performance, wait time and unload time, it’s easier to make pivotal decisions about carrier choice and how best to optimize dock labor for speedy loading and unloading.
A YMS provides real-time visibility into asset locations and their operational status, including dwell times in various states. By monitoring all the delays in the visit lifecycle, it becomes possible to streamline operations, for instance by rapidly identifying available empty trailers for outbound loads.
An effective YMS can ensure that every trailer, tractor and driver entering the facility is checked in and out in a consistent manner. Seals are checked, damage is recorded and shipment information is associated with the trailer number.
Continual process improvement
A modern YMS provides shippers and 3PLs with reports and analytics for effective KPI setting and measurement. When performance expectations aren’t satisfactorily met, managers can quickly pinpoint which functions of the supply chain need intervention.
Spotter/yard jockey efficiency
A YMS greatly improves spotter move times and enables shuttle drivers to electronically receive, accept and confirm completion of move requests, eliminating radio communication.
Top shippers and 3PLs collaborate with their carriers. This collaboration includes providing carriers with access to the YMS, so real-time shipment notifications can be sent.
A YMS can improve safety by eliminating the need to have people walking around the yard performing manual checks. Instrumentation on yard trucks monitors speed, safe practices and hours of service for yard truck drivers. The YMS also helps secure the yard by tracking all moves from check-in to check-out.
Yard of yards
Companies with multiple yards do not have access to a single view of all their facilities without a YMS. The network view allows organizations to pool assets, including empty trailers and yard trucks, and to compare operational effectiveness across all locations.
The combination of YMS with dock-door scheduling, WMS and workforce management can significantly aid in the ability to efficiently cross-dock high volumes of products and materials through facilities.
The next-generation YMS provides shippers and carriers with an integrated appointment scheduling portal to replace time-consuming communication methods, like email and phone calls.
Like all carriers, we feel the acute pain of appointment management every single day. Our dispatchers manage an incredibly complex workflow, which involves managing scheduling and rescheduling across many different platforms… FourKites’ Appointment Manager, which is the first universal platform that integrates with all of our systems, would save our dispatchers approximately eight hours a week, and allow them to shift their focus to higher-value tasks.
– Sanford Gruhn, Director of Sales at K&B Transportation, Inc.
In this infographic, you’ll find unique insights into the state of yard and appointment management across industries, pain points by industry, and areas organizations have identified as opportunities for improvement.
How Has COVID-19 Impacted Yard Management?
Trends in yard management
COVID-19 has presented entirely new and unforeseen challenges across supply chains everywhere. Specifically when it comes to yard management, these roadblocks have shed light on specific areas of weakness, and highlighted opportunities for preventing future breakdowns through automation and digitization. Some of the specific impacts of COVID-19 on yard operations include:
- Companies adjusting their business models and processes to adjust to heightened customer demands and changing consumer behaviors.
- Companies adopting technology by increasing utilization of their existing applications, as well as interest in new applications, such as yard management software.
- Social distancing forcing companies to rethink processes to improve the safety of front-line workers.
Due to the changing landscape of yard management, companies are increasingly relying on technology – particularly mobile applications – and shifting their focus to digitization and automation of existing processes. As in-transit freight visibility becomes increasingly effective, shippers and 3PLs have begun to express increased desire for alignment between yard and transportation visibility, along with improved carrier communication and alignment.
Maximizing Agility in the Face of Crisis
We have seen several effects of COVID-19. Companies have adjusted their business models and processes to adjust to new and changed customer demands, as well as consumer behaviors.
– Bart De Muynck, Vice President Analyst, Gartner
How are yard management solutions addressing the challenges arising from COVID-19? We’re seeing increasing adoption of the following technologies:
Better transit data
Visibility solutions are able to get better and more predictable data around transit, resulting in more accurate scheduling of shipments and better on-time delivery.
Dynamic appointment scheduling
Disruptions in the supply chain have highlighted the need for yard management software to bring about improved accuracy and carrier empowerment via dynamic appointment scheduling. This enables carriers to update appointment windows and alerts them when another stakeholder changes the schedule.
Automation of gate processes
For the safety of carriers and frontline supply chain workers, yard management systems have implemented gate process automation. In addition to promoting safety, it also improves accuracy and speed by eliminating the possibility of human error at the gate.
Electronic documentation replaces physical documentation, improving carrier and customer communication and collaboration, and reducing the chance of spreading germs through physical copies. Additionally, this eliminates time spent searching for physical copies of documents, and emailing or faxing them to various stakeholders.
Electronic signatures can be collected remotely while safeguarding the driver. The use of electronic proofs of delivery (PODs) provides instant updates, in turn increasing the speed and automation of invoicing.
The use of emerging technologies, such as autonomous vehicles and advanced analytics or AI/ML, optimizes routes and promotes continual improvement.
The ROI of a Yard Management Solution
Although in general we see a decline in overall spend in supply chain management applications in 2020, transportation and yard technologies continue to see strong adoption.
– Bart De Muynck, Vice President Analyst, Gartner
ROI can come from multiple areas, including reduced detention/demurrage costs through increased visibility to trailer status and dwell times; reduced labor expense with more efficient yard jockeys; reduced infrastructure costs from reduced need for yard vehicles; and more.
For many companies, reduced detention expense has been the largest area of improvement in the yard, with real-time trailer and load status awareness being the biggest drivers of reducing those expenses. While the biggest impacts on ROI can be site-dependent, the average YMS implementation carries the following returns on investment:
- Increased workforce efficiency by 25-30%
- Increased throughput at the dock by 20-40%
- Decreased detention costs by 40-80%
- Total estimated savings per year: $99,752
Total estimated savings calculated based on the following assumptions:
- 2 Spotter Units at $110,000 per year
- Spotters performing manual yard checks for 120 hours at $20 per hour
- Office staff communicating with carriers for 30 hours per month at an hourly rate of $20
- Analysts creating reports for 10 hours per month at a rate of $20 per hour
- Managers performing internal inquiry requests for 10 hours per month at an hourly rate of $20
- Office staff looking up historical moves for 8 hours per month at $20 per hour
- Office staff performing other external inquiries for 8 hours per month at $20 per month
- Average monthly demurrage / detention cost of $4000
ROI estimates provided by Royal4 Systems.
Best Yard Management Software Vendors
Choosing the right yard management solution requires a thorough assessment of the needs and goals of an organization. Your company may need in-depth yard management, an end-to-end in-transit visibility solution or a less comprehensive solution. Regardless of the outcome of this assessment, a digital solution can help to automate and optimize the yard operations for organizations of any size.
The following breakdown highlights key differences across solution providers:
|Application mega-suite vendors||Oracle, SAP||These vendors offer broad portfolios of applications across most application categories (e.g., back-office financials, supply chain management [SCM], logistics, CRM and product life cycle management [PLM]).|
|Supply chain management suite vendors||4Sight, Aptean, Blue Yonder, BluJay Solutions, HighJump, Inconso, Inform, Manhattan Associates, NCR Retalix, ProAct International, Reply, Softeon, Transporeon, UltraShip, Zebra||These vendors offer a portfolio of applications focused primarily on SCM, including aspects of logistics, but not other functional areas such as financials or human capital management. While these vendors might offer a variety of SCM solutions, not all of them offer an integrated platform.|
|Supply chain visibility vendors||FourKites||These vendors are independent software vendors (ISVs) that focus primarily or exclusively on real-time supply chain visibility, specializing in yard management. Such platforms provide a holistic, end-to-end view of the lifecycle of any given load.|
|Specialist YMS vendors||C3 Solutions, Cypress Inland Corporation, Pinc||These vendors are independent software vendors (ISVs) that focus primarily or exclusively on holistic YMS, although they might offer some additional capabilities.|
Most yard management solutions offer minimal appointment, gate and inventory management functionality. The most comprehensive platforms also offer metrics, dock management and carrier tools. Over the next few years, the best YMS software vendors will invest in:
- Capabilities supported by 5G networks
- The use of AI to scan bills of lading (BOLs) and support contactless gate check-in and receiving
- Autonomous, sustainable yard vehicles
- Trailer load optimization technologies through cameras enabled by AI
- Real-time visibility across the supply chain
What Is Dynamic Yard?
In the same way that FourKites redefined supply chain management with real-time visibility, it is now delivering real-time visibility to the yard. Unlike traditional, siloed yard management solutions, Dynamic Yard offers the unprecedented ability to manage every aspect of your yard operations from a single tool.
FourKites’ Dynamic Yard could become a game-changing solution for us. Our existing YMS is limited when it comes to understanding the real-time status of our freight. FourKites took the opportunity to work with us to understand our need to optimize operations based on tracking and predictive ETA data. Dynamic Yard…could be a real breakthrough that enables cost savings and significant gains in efficiency.
– Belinda Biddle, Customer Experience Manager, Transportation GE Appliances
Here’s what sets Dynamic Yard apart from other solutions on the market.
|Scalability||Scalable enterprise solutions for any organization, regardless of size – from the smallest up to multiple enterprise locations. No matter the size and number of sites, Dynamic Yard provides comprehensive reporting and metrics to make sure every site is performing to its potential.|
|Process Automation||Manual processes keep today’s supply chains from reaching true optimization. Dynamic Yard automates the most basic functions of your yard, freeing up resources to handle higher-value tasks.
Spotter task workflow automation and automated alerting and report emails are just a few ways Dynamic Yard streamlines on-site workflows.
|Multi-Tenant Visibility||For your supply chain to run smoothly, every stakeholder must be informed of changes happening at every level. Using portals designed specifically for the needs of your carriers and individual sites, your stakeholders are empowered to view changes, manage appointments and complete tasks with ease.|
|Robust Integrations||By integrating with your TMS and WMS, Dynamic Yard provides the full picture of your operations. With comprehensive data at your fingertips, Dynamic Yard serves as your single source of truth for centralized performance analysis and monitoring.|
|Easy, Rapid Deployment||With an 8-week standard deployment, FourKites has mastered the balance between deployment speed, meticulousness and time to value. Our team works with you every step of the way to ensure successful deployment.|
Yard management solutions have to evolve for the future. We take great pride in the fact that we’ve built this with the input of our supply chain stakeholders, and that, through ongoing conversations with our customers, we’re building the next-generation YMS.
– Priya Rajagopalan, FourKites’ Chief Product Officer